Fugate Introduces Bill to Stop Use of Credit Scores in Setting Insurance Rates
OKLAHOMA CITY – Rep. Andy Fugate, D–Del City, introduced House Bill 4286 to prohibit insurance companies from using a person’s credit history or credit score to determine the rates they pay for insurance. The measure is designed to protect hardworking Oklahomans who are being priced out of basic financial stability by an insurance system that punishes people for their credit history rather than their actual risk. “Insurance is unlike any other product,” Fugate said. “If someone fails to pay for a car, it must be repossessed. If they fail to pay for a home, they must be evicted. That takes time and effort. But if someone fails to pay their insurance bill, the company simply denies the claim. Period. There is no financial risk to the insurer that justifies using credit scores as a backdoor way to raise rates.” While the practice affects all insurance, Fugate emphasized that the most devastating impact is on home insurance — where Oklahoma already has some of the highest premiums in the nation. Those inflated premiums are shutting hardworking families out of homeownership. “Right now, a young couple can find a starter home with a mortgage payment they can afford,” Fugate said. “But when they go to close, they discover their homeowner insurance premium is so inflated because of their credit score that their escrow payment becomes unaffordable. They lose the home, not because they cannot afford the house, but because they cannot afford the insurance.” Fugate noted that this creates a perverse system where families with limited or poor credit are blocked from building wealth, while investors with excellent credit can swoop in, buy the same home, and rent it back to them at a profit. “That’s not a free market. That’s a rigged market,” Fugate said. “Hardworking Oklahomans are being priced out of the American dream while someone with better credit buys the home, charges them rent, pays less for the insurance, and makes a profit. That’s upside?down.” Testimony from an interim study last fall underscored how disconnected current insurance pricing is from real?world risk. Lawmakers heard that an Oklahoman with a spotless driving record but poor credit could pay more for car insurance than a neighbor with multiple accidents but excellent credit. “That example stunned people,” Fugate said. “It shows exactly why this practice is unfair, unproductive, and completely disconnected from actual behavior. Whether driving or maintaining a home, insurance rates should be based on risk, not on whether someone went through a tough financial stretch.” Fugate said the bill is part of his broader commitment to ensuring Oklahoma’s laws work for regular people, not just those with wealth or perfect credit histories. “Oklahomans deserve a fair shot,” he said. “Your insurance rate should reflect your real?world risk, not your credit score. This bill restores common sense and protects hardworking families who are being crushed by outrageous premiums.” The legislation will be considered during the upcoming session. Fugate encouraged Oklahomans to contact their legislators and urge them to support the measure. “Every Oklahoman deserves the chance to pursue the American Dream. Buy a home, raise a family, and build a future,” Fugate said. “This bill will bring back that dream for a new generation of Oklahomans.” -END-

